[ home ] [ site / arch ] [ pony / oat / anon ] [ rp / art ]

/rp/ - Roleplaying

The board for roleplaying and roleplaying discussion.
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Flags
Password (For file deletion.)

Site maintenance in progress! Posts made now may be lost.

Ponychan-MLPchan Merger >>>/site/15219

File: 1412899691793.gif (964.52 KB, 400x240, gs5-gavel_zps5bcc3e9d.gif)

Ace Attorney: The Spells of Truth Case 2: Music and Turnabout Judge !4DoxwKTFKs 839107[View All]

453 posts and 432 image replies omitted. Click View to see all.

Aya Shameimaru !MJ7QOwb7Ts 845565

File: 1414313871874.png (140.81 KB, 640x480, ayaidle_ridiculouslysmug.png)

>>845562
Alas, your floundering attempts are the least bit of a worry. Good try though.

>What killed Miss Melody, and how? Death was instantaneous, mind you.


Simple. Many things can kill you if you're hit hard enough with them. I can drive a cup into your skull at mach 1. But that's not what we're talking about here.

Simple fact is, if Bon Bon did it, you'll probably never find the murder weapon now. Probably at the bottom of a cliff somewhere. As for your "died instantly", simple. Vinyl hit Octavia which didn't kill her, and then Bon Bon smashed her in the same spot hard enough to kill her instantly.
Satisfied?

>You simply have absolutely no evidence that proves, without a doubt, that all of these actions occurred.


>Exhibit 1. Autopsy Report

Exhibit one single-handedly proves that she died instantly, proving my point above.

>Exhibit 2. Stack of Vinyl Records

Exhibit 2 proves they were not in a box, meaning they were not enough to murder Octavia.

>Exhibit 3. Time of Concert Showings

Exhibit 3 proves to me that Octavia was basically there at the scene of the crime.

>Exhibit 4. Backstage Pass

Exhibit 4 proves that Vinyl Scratch was there.

>Exhibit 5. Access Records

Exhibit 5 probes that Bon Bon left at 2:30 and couldn't get in after, and that Upper Crust left for seemingly no reason at 5:40 no doubt to pick up Bon Bon.

>Exhibit 6. Box of Bon Bons shaped like a Cello.

Exhibit 6 proves that Bon Bon had earlier known the location of Octavia Melody's room to murder herr.

>Exhibit 7. Receipt

Exhibit 7 proves that these Bon Bons were in fact brought.

>Exhibit 8. Love Letters

>Exhibit 9. Letter
Exhibit 8 and 9 proves that Bon Bon had a motive to kill Octavia and also proves that Upper Crust knew about this.


>You claim that the murder weapon is not the murder weapon. You claim that the murder is someone else.

Didn't want further reading, but if you really want it, I guess there's nothing else to do. Did I mention I really like Science for some reason?
Take a look at the stacks of vinyl.

>Exhibit 2. Stack of Vinyl Records

>Used to murder the victim, Octavia. Bears Vinyl Scratch’s magical aura.
They were kept in a stack, not a box.
I'd like to point out that ponies are actually about half our size. Their heads however are the same length as ours, which means a vinyl disk is about half the size of them too.
Now, there's 1KG in a N. Let's say it takes about... uh, 10N.
That would require you to swing the box about 20 times stronger than the force of gravity.
Now, assuming this stack is 60 centimeters tall and bound in wrapping, and had a length of 35 centimeters and a thickness of 3 millimeters, the entire stack alone would have weighed 630 grams.
For a figure of how heavy that is, it's about the weight of a 20 pack of toilet paper, perhaps. Or maybe two bags of peanuts. Heavy, no? Real capable of murder.
In short, not only do you have to swing the box basically hard enough to cause an earthquake to kill someone, it also probably weighs only slightly more than Mr. Edgeworth's head.

Unfortunately for you, Mr. Edgeworth, either all the evidence backs me up or has no relevance to either of our cases. Bad form.
What's next?

1/2 Judge !4DoxwKTFKs 845566

File: 1414313980150.gif (541.67 KB, 507x272, Disagree.gif)

>>845565
Miss Shameimaru, I'm afraid there is something critically wrong here.

2/2 Judge !4DoxwKTFKs 845567

File: 1414314745722.gif (426.68 KB, 507x272, Speaking.gif)

>>845566

You are still unable to place Bon Bon at the crime scene. This is all theoretical. Each piece of evidence you have shown has already been used against you by the prosecution. You can not place Bon Bon at the crime scene at the very specific time of 5 PM to give her her instantaneous death. Not only that, but even though I am no scientist, I doubt the sciences behind your calculations. I still believe that the murder weapon that the Prosecution submitted could be still legitimate. I'm sorry, but the Prosecution's claims are upheld, and your's are not. Despite the sciences behind this, Vinyl Scratch is still the only one who could have done this. You can not prove that Bon Bon had teleported in and out, or anyone else, for that matter. The Prosecution proved Vinyl Scratch's appearance at the crime scene, at the specified time.

Because you can not submit a murder weapon, I do admit, that this looks bad for both sides, however, the Prosecution's argument has been constant, while the Defense has been practically grasping at straws. You tried, and you tried well, Miss Shameimaru, but I'm afraid this is over. This is the final day of trial, and I have heard various testimonies. I have listened to all of the arguments of the court room, and I am nearly inclined to side with the Defense, however, the lack of strong evidence still makes me weary. I'm afraid without the crucial evidence, it all goes down to argumentative and debating skills. Who has had the strongest, most consistent argument? That is the question that I have the answer to.


I will only deliver half the penalty, meaning, The Defense now only has 2 and a half marks left, not that it matters too much.

If no one has any further objections, I will announce my verdict

Miles Edgeworth 845568

File: 1414315573519.gif (655.12 KB, 500x294, EdgeworthPointing.gif)

>>845567
Your Honour, if I may please have one moment before you announce your verdict. Since the current murder weapon is being called into question, I do believe the Prosecution can submit a different item.

Judge !4DoxwKTFKs 845569

File: 1414315629078.gif (450.94 KB, 507x272, Thinking.gif)

>>845568

Very well then, Mr. Edgeworth. Present your evidence!

Miles Edgeworth 845570

File: 1414315700396.gif (748.62 KB, 500x290, EdgeworthDeskSlam.gif)

>>845569

TAKE THAT!

>Box of Chocolates presented


Your Honour, this is the murder weapon we are looking for!

Judge !4DoxwKTFKs 845571

File: 1414315745449.gif (572.55 KB, 507x272, Shocked-Speaking.gif)

>>845570
Mr. Edgeworth! I'm confused! Please, elaborate!

1/2 Miles Edgeworth 845572

File: 1414315913183.gif (138.02 KB, 256x192, Zoom.gif)

>>845571

It is simple, Your Honour! The chocolates were poisoned! Never once did we question if the box was opened or not! If the box was opened, and Octavia Melody ate one of the chocolates, then it is not hard to assume that she may have died from poisoning instead!

Ergo, the Prosecution indicts both Vinyl Scratch, and Bon Bon of murder! They were accomplices from the start!

2/2 Miles Edgeworth 845573

File: 1414316074705.gif (655.12 KB, 500x294, EdgeworthPointing.gif)

>>845572

The Prosecution asserts that there was a rather high-tense love triangle between the three mares. Eventually, a plot was formed to get rid of the one causing the most problems, Octavia Melody. This explains why Vinyl Scratch was in the possession of Octavia's letters, because Bon Bon showed them to her!

Bon Bon had poisoned the chocolates, and Vinyl Scratch committed the assault! It was a deadly two-punch combo.

The Prosecution, now rests.

1/2 Judge !4DoxwKTFKs 845574

File: 1414316195265.gif (426.68 KB, 507x272, Speaking.gif)

>>845573
That... That's rather convincing, Mr. Edgeworth! I... I can't believe what I just heard! It seems Mr. Wright has rubbed off on you after all these years.

Now, I am sure that I can announce a true, correct verdict.

This Court finds the Accused, Vinyl Scratch and Bon Bon, GUILTY!

1/2 Judge !4DoxwKTFKs 845575

File: 1414316211443.gif (964.52 KB, 400x240, gs5-gavel_zps5bcc3e9d.gif)

>>845574
Court is now dismissed!

Judge !4DoxwKTFKs 845576

File: 1414316816029.gif (61.89 KB, 78x108, guilty.gif)

>>845574
for dramatic effect

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845659

File: 1414360346803.jpg (603.59 KB, 1028x1069, 103634__anthro_princess+luna_s…)

"Well this was certainly interesting."

Miles Edgeworth !vk2noctis. 845786

File: 1414378350988.gif (296.09 KB, 500x293, Edgeworth Grin.gif)

>>845659

In the pursuit of justice and the truth, anything can happen. What happened here, was indeed quite interesting.

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845792

File: 1414378596991.jpg (1.51 MB, 1891x2500, 717206__safe_solo_anthro_princ…)

>>845786
"Yes, but Bon Bon beig guilty too? That was some serious suspense, and completely unexpected. I just hope Miss Crust didn't give you a bad impression on high society."

Miles Edgeworth !vk2noctis. 845795

File: 1414378729811.gif (363.22 KB, 500x298, EdgeworthFront2.gif)

>>845792

Indeed, it was quite a surprising revelation. I did not think that Bon Bon would commit a crime. She was already in court once before as a defendant. However, using the Defense's logic, there was only one true outcome. I have met with other High Society ponies, worry not. Upper Crust is the fine example of the stereotype, however.

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845799

File: 1414378969161.jpg (594.62 KB, 1280x891, 382191__safe_solo_anthro_princ…)

>>845795
"Perhaps she wasn't aware she was committing a crime. Vinyl may have laced the chocolates she made with the poison. I am glad you know that she is pretty much the stereotype, if not. I'd have tried to introduce you to Fancy Pants. High society, and very nice."

Miles Edgeworth !vk2noctis. 845802

File: 1414379144720.gif (319.59 KB, 500x293, EdgeworthSpeakingFront.gif)

>>845799

Well, now that they are both in jail, this is their time to redeem themselves. We will naturally interrogate them further until we find out how it was exactly executed. Fancypants was a nice stallion indeed. In fact I had already met him once before.

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845804

File: 1414379266330.jpg (334.89 KB, 836x1069, 657932__safe_solo_anthro_princ…)

>>845802
"I certainly hope you get the answers you're looking for out of them Mr. Edgeworth. It's always a shame when a pony has their life taken from them. I'm just hoping that Bon Bon didn't have a direct hand, or hoof rather, in this whole mess. Vinyl could have laced them after all."

Miles Edgeworth !vk2noctis. 845806

File: 1414379384551.gif (363.22 KB, 500x298, EdgeworthFront2.gif)

>>845804
We shall see.

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845807

File: 1414379574296.png (449.66 KB, 800x800, 90627__anthro_princess+luna_pr…)

>>845806
"Can't help a Princess who has wishful thinking. But I know you'll get your answers. Good job on beating your father in Court by the way."

Miles Edgeworth !vk2noctis. 845809

File: 1414379707303.gif (363.22 KB, 500x298, EdgeworthFront2.gif)

>>845807
It was definitely a struggle to defeat Gregory Edgeworth. I did not want to defeat him, but the truth can not remain in the shadows.

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845811

File: 1414379821826.jpg (746.89 KB, 1149x1377, 215972__anthro_princess+luna_s…)

>>845809
"I was more congratulating you because I'm hoping he's proud you've proven yourself as a very capable lawyer in front of him."

Miles Edgeworth !vk2noctis. 845812

File: 1414379929302.gif (1.01 MB, 500x297, tumblr_inline_ndjq28OaFM1qkpnr…)

>>845811
Ah, I see. I'm sure I have made him proud. I hold quite the important office at the Prosecutor's office. For the longest time, all I ever wanted to do was make him proud. I'm quite sure I've succeeded. Thank you, Princess.

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845813

File: 1414380002747.jpg (968.03 KB, 1088x1695, 277146__safe_anthro_princess+l…)

>>845812
"You're quite welcome Mr. Edgeworth."

Anonymous 845847

File: 1414385812279.gif (539.29 KB, 291x362, Apollo Bashful.gif)

Wow.
This all was.
Wow.

Haha. This was definitely Case 5 stuff.

Mia Fey 845848

File: 1414386056891.gif (691.05 KB, 960x640, Animation_011.gif)

Just pretend I posted this earler, Kay? This needed more drama.

>>845516
...

Apollo Justice !H44/JpR3nw 845849

File: 1414386058826.gif (1006.43 KB, 332x367, Apollo Grin.gif)

>>845376
>Let them speak without penalty


Swag.

Mia Fey 845851

>>845848

*door slam*

Miles Edgeworth 845852

File: 1414386321237.gif (236.09 KB, 500x297, EdgeworthFront.gif)

>>845847
What can I say? I went a tad overboard in my prosecuting. The tension picked up right where it left off, if not having become more tense

>>845849
Wouldn't be too fun if the Defense always got penalized, now would it?

Apollo Justice !H44/JpR3nw 845855

File: 1414386407595.gif (778.53 KB, 318x350, Apollo Discouraged.gif)

>>845852
Yeah.
Especially considering how the Prosecution NEVER gets penalized.

Miles Edgeworth 845857

File: 1414386554525.gif (977.55 KB, 500x290, EdgeworthShake.gif)

>>845855
What can I say? The prosecution can do no wrong, Mr. Justice

>>845813
Enjoy your evening, Princess. I do suppose I'll see you some other time.

Apollo Justice !H44/JpR3nw 845858

>>845857
[insert kappa here]

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845862

File: 1414387143489.jpg (128.43 KB, 1124x1280, 16110__anthro_princess+luna_su…)

>>845857
"I am enjoying my evening. Thank you."

Phoenix Wright!Vn48qlRnx2 845877

File: 1414407969408.gif (83.49 KB, 256x192, phoenix-thinking(a).gif)

>>845857
Why dont we add her to the group edge?

Miles Edgeworth !vk2noctis. 845915

File: 1414418869745.gif (977.55 KB, 500x290, EdgeworthShake.gif)

>>845877
Simple-minded as ever, I see, Wright. We've merely never asked if she was interested. We don't want to seem as though we desperately need others. For some, they prefer to only post in the threads.

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845917

File: 1414423967965.png (714.13 KB, 800x1080, 565550__safe_solo_anthro_princ…)

>>845877
>>845915
>I wouldn't mind being added, got a Skype for me to add?
>Phoenix did ask if I was interested before Mr. Edgeworth, I was just a little unsure about it at the time.
This post was edited by its author on .

Miles Edgeworth 845938

>>845917
You may contact me at my skype MasterLegend359

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 845939

File: 1414432461391.jpg (128.43 KB, 1124x1280, 16110__anthro_princess+luna_su…)

>>845938
>Done and done.

1/2 ??? 846030

File: 1414443181420.png (142.5 KB, 333x237, AA5_Holdit.png)

2/2 Princess Celestia 846032

File: 1414443362096.gif (1.05 MB, 256x192, (b)normal.gif)

>>846030

I'm afraid this case is now being appealed to a higher court. I please ask that the Defense and Prosecution remain the attorneys assigned to this case. This is a very unique case. Due to interrogations going nowhere, the Prosecution has insisted on finding the truth the only other way possible, through trial.

Day 4 TBD

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 846052

File: 1414449995680.jpg (94 KB, 707x997, 721847__safe_solo_anthro_princ…)

>>846032
"This is going to be good." Said sitting where the audience is supposed to sit.

Apollo Justice !H44/JpR3nw 846313

File: 1414483766269.jpg (Spoiler Image,209.45 KB, 1600x900, OHNOOHYESOHBABY.jpg)

>>846032
>Day 4
>Higher Court
>Finding the truth

MLG levels of Rising from the Ashes are being reached.

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 846319

File: 1414507644555.png (27.41 KB, 195x237, phil happy.png)

>>846313
>Like a Phoenix, Mother F**ker!

Anonymous 846419

>>846319
get it? Phoenix Wright? That's the joke... fuck

Princess Luna!ANTHROkUqY 846421

File: 1414520692707.jpg (351.06 KB, 850x1100, 25572__safe_solo_anthro_prince…)

>>846419
>That too!

Anonymous 851524

>>846030
>>846032
Aren't you aware that you posted a day late?
>implying that they are trying to keep someone (or somepony) from being guilty.

Anonymous 851525

File: 1415491583534.gif (570.06 KB, 500x295, EdgeworthThinkSpeak.gif)

>>851524
Aren't you aware that this person is with us? To be honest, we've just had scheduling issues and all that prevent us from moving forward.

A day 4 is very unorthodox and has never been done before. It even breaks series canon, but there was one member of the crew that really wanted it.

Anonymous 851970

>>851525
>breaks canon
Nay.
We make our own canon.

Miles Edgeworth !vk2noctis. 858442

File: 1416733592110.gif (123.58 KB, 256x192, miles-normal(b).gif)

https://mlpchan.net/rp/res/858334.html
Day 4 is happening. We are currently investigating, but it is happening. Court convenes next week.


Delete Post [ ]
Edit Post
[ home ] [ site / arch ] [ pony / oat / anon ] [ rp / art ]