Meh, nevermind, here goes nothing. Ended up going with a mix, mostly based on how much I enjoyed them and how much there was of value in an episode. deleted previous post and posted again to make the graph easier to read
Rough descriprions of the ratings in case you care. Also, these are things the episode might be, but to classify as a seven or 4 it didn't necessarily have to have all the qualities I mentioned. They are merely rough guidelines.
1 = I hated it, not redeemable in any way, absolutely worst, disgusting
2 = Severerely flawed, nigh irredeemable, has very little positives, but has some
3 = Fairly flawed, some positives that might make it worth watching, left a bad taste
4 = left a slightly bad taste in my mouth, overall a negative feeling but only slightly
5 = slightly negative but mostly meh, no strong feelings
6= slightly positive but mostly meh, no strong feelings
7 = more good than bad, but only slightly, has flaws but its positives slightly outweigh them, left a good feeling but not necessarily otherwise awesome
8 = Good but not super.
9 = really good feels, not the best of the best but maybe close, small flaws
10 = absolutely loved it, flawless, best of the best