[ home ] [ site / arch ] [ pony / oat / anon ] [ rp / art ]

/oat/ - Off Topic

The OT board for chatting, /oat/meal, socializing serials, and random topics.
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Flags
Password (For file deletion.)

Site maintenance in progress! Posts made now may be lost.

Ponychan-MLPchan Merger >>>/site/15219

File: 1428108825091.png (116.69 KB, 1068x1050, mlpti.png)

Heavy Mole 3225328

My MLP mbti chart.

So that future generations will know.

Personality types are grouped according to functional constituency; this produces four basic "temperaments", or world views, which appear to have precedent in some ancient classification systems (the four humors, the four suits of the tarot, etc.).

Diametrically opposed personality types in this model are complementary: for instance, INFJ and ESTP (types connected by the outer oblique lines also have implicate relationships, which I won't go into here). There are also "sister" types: for instance, ISFJ and ESFJ, which are literally sisters here!

3225334

I wanna see, anthro Rarity and Twilight Sparkle Clopping

post CMC PVH porny images from strangerdanger- in this thread

>Lewkin at Fall of Equestria Teen Cheerleaders in afterdark

Anonthony!AppLeJAcK. 3225375

i dont know what i am

Anonymous 3225385

>>3225375
you're FGT

Anonthony!AppLeJAcK. 3225402

Anonthony!AppLeJAcK. 3225406

File: 1428112737585.png (9.18 KB, 686x374, Screenshot_2.png)

Anonthony!AppLeJAcK. 3225409

so pretty solidly IN_J, with 50/50 nearly T/F

so either INFJ or INTJ

Heavy Mole 3225417

File: 1428113111801.png (206.67 KB, 274x428, lucy349.png)

>>3225402
Called it!

Anonthony!AppLeJAcK. 3225432

>>3225417
Introverted (yes), iNtuitive (yes), Thinking/Feeling mix (yes), Judging (yes).

Heavy Mole 3225475

File: 1428114523927.jpg (2.75 KB, 104x118, lucy10.jpg)

>>3225432
The mbti labels are convenient but can be a little misleading. INTJ and INFJ are actually quite different, despite being only one letter apart: the INTJ has extraverted thinking and introverted feeling, while the INFJ has extraverted feeling and introverted thinking. In the diagram, you can see that they belong to different temperaments.

In a heated argument, for example, an INFJ will fall back on internal logical determinations (introverted thinking), while the INTJ will resort to the force of their personal convictions in the face of opposition (introverted feeling).

These are only intuitively conceived patterns, of course, but they are interesting to observe.

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225479

File: 1428114592223.jpg (108.58 KB, 945x945, 132623840376.jpg)

y-yee

Heavy Mole 3225485

File: 1428114695367.png (33.27 KB, 159x151, lucy173.png)

>>3225479
That actually makes total sense.

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225489

File: 1428114748802.jpg (110.75 KB, 413x554, 132623917661.jpg)

>>3225485
You're just saying that because it's your chart, you filthy liar.

Heavy Mole 3225497

File: 1428114923638.png (69.28 KB, 236x248, lucy154.png)

>>3225489
A happy coincidence!

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225500

File: 1428114991531.png (93.43 KB, 308x700, 132625890544.png)

>>3225497
I demand you to tell me what the coincidence is.

Heavy Mole 3225514

File: 1428115194628.jpg (57.63 KB, 640x480, lucy207.jpg)

>>3225500
That finally settled on a sense of your mbti type, and that I was aided to that understanding through a diagram of fictional characters that I made.

Of course, if it doesn't make sense to you, into the bonfire it goes.

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225524

File: 1428115353699.png (269.33 KB, 670x670, 132623874970.png)

>>3225514
I'm having difficulty understanding your sentence structure, and Rarity is probably much better with fancy sentence structuring than I am, so bonfire seems like a sensible possibility.

Heavy Mole 3225543

File: 1428115626519.png (75.48 KB, 235x250, lucy14.png)

>>3225524
Oh. Well, what I meant to say was that my type choice for Rarity helped me make sense of how you typed, and how you typed in turn confirmed my choice for Rarity. If that makes any sense.

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225551

File: 1428115729375.jpg (209.46 KB, 1015x720, 132632910142.jpg)

>>3225543
Well ah sure ain't gonna type like a gosh darn redneck, y'hear?

Heavy Mole 3225564

File: 1428115992700.jpg (13.29 KB, 192x115, lucy113.jpg)

>>3225551
Actually the giveaway for me was how much you despise lying and deception.

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225567

File: 1428116038361.jpg (24.51 KB, 600x338, 132624037614.jpg)

>>3225564
Then I should have been Applejack, right?

Heavy Mole 3225589

File: 1428116512973.jpg (181.78 KB, 356x1208, lucy234_dcrisisbeta.jpg)

>>3225567
It would seem so, but it's subtle. Applejack seems more oriented toward fulfillment of duty and is embarrassed when there's an apparent breach of that in her self-image. For example, Applebuck Season, that episode where she doesn't return home after winning fourth place medals at a rodeo, being angry about being recorded as "sleeping on the job" by Gabby Gums, etc.

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225603

File: 1428116829974.png (338.6 KB, 800x600, 132624209054.png)

>>3225589
I bet I could've been an Applejack if I wasn't such a failure.

Heavy Mole 3225610

File: 1428117112310.jpg (46.15 KB, 599x528, lucy361.jpg)

>>3225603
None of the individual types are 'better' than any other. They can be thought of as different intelligent roles which we have a natural propensity toward.

Here, if you have time, watch this. See if it resonates with you. Again, we're just talking intuitively thought up patterns, but it can be useful information to have and reflect on.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9dqqGGUEN60

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225622

File: 1428117389673.jpg (177.76 KB, 976x963, 132634847057.jpg)

>>3225610
These stuff always feel like fortune telling to me, as long as it sounds nice enough, it will surely resonate anyway. I think I will refuse to watch all the way, sorry.
Besides, I stopped identifying with it when it said things like "strong" and "knowledge".

Heavy Mole 3225639

File: 1428117657120.jpg (153.26 KB, 900x613, lucy233_furrysketch.jpg)

>>3225622
Maybe for the best, then. Trust your instinct.

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225643

File: 1428117698548.png (175.83 KB, 955x1063, 132624033132.png)

>>3225639
My instincts are dead.

Heavy Mole 3225663

File: 1428117961830.png (44.95 KB, 138x205, lucy144.png)

>>3225643
Say, would you entertain the idea of going on a picnic?

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3225676

File: 1428118128405.jpg (105.06 KB, 550x697, 843424__twilight+sparkle_anthr…)

>tfw Twispike

Thauma!TURTLEsW8. 3225677

File: 1428118132479.png (257.12 KB, 853x800, 1401905459666.png)

>>3225663
A picnic? I've always loved the idea, but haven't done it more than once or twice...
We have to find others though, otherwise it'd be gay. Keep me posted.

I go bed, good night!

Heavy Mole 3225682

File: 1428118250765.png (53.37 KB, 156x225, lucy148.png)

>>3225676
Uh... leaning toward Twilight, I'd say...

>>3225677
Night!

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3225690

File: 1428118353170.png (344.42 KB, 675x643, 844402__safe_twilight+sparkle_…)

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3225801

File: 1428121190062.gif (990.8 KB, 479x521, 685955__safe_solo_applejack_an…)

>>3225379
>take this particular mbti test
>get ISTJ

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3225809

File: 1428121321080.gif (94.49 KB, 119x125, Applejack wut (auto).gif)

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3225815

File: 1428121440848.gif (88.88 KB, 125x125, Applejack wut (auto) (2.gif)

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3225817

File: 1428121473958.gif (60.67 KB, 125x125, Applejack wat auto close.gif)

Heavy Mole 3225823

File: 1428121602041.jpg (44.92 KB, 500x500, lucy128.jpg)

>>3225809
>>3225815
>>3225817
You, an extraverted thinker? I'm not sure about that...

Anonthony!AppLeJAcK. 3225870

but i dont get how as intj thats diamond tiara

i think i get the other part, that about others i think and about self i feel. or something.

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3225872

File: 1428123016601.png (352.17 KB, 1098x1100, Diamond Tiara dresses Rumble u…)

>>3225870
Maybe you don't understand Diamond Tiara well enough.

Maybe if you got to know her better, you'd understand and like what she does.

Admiral 3225882

>Trixie
Every time tho.

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3225892

>>3225882
If you're a boy it's Gaston.

Admiral 3225899

>>3225892
Says who?

Heavy Mole 3228743

File: 1428205172908.png (583.12 KB, 1280x720, Adagio_Dazzle_in_shock_and_awe…)

>>3225870
Mmm. Diamond's really leans more toward being an ENTJ, admittedly. I was trying to confine my choices to the first season. I wanted it so badly to be perfect!

A better example of an INTJ MLP character is Adagio Dazzle. Note how she's less interested in leadership per se than she is a kind of "will-to-power"--a domination of her environment through intuitive apprehension. She's also fiercely independent and oriented toward self-possession. Her surroundings become a tool for her to achieve that aim, rather than the aim itself.

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3228813

File: 1428206845847.gif (595.73 KB, 638x647, Rainbow squee blush.gif)

>>3228743
>A better example of an INTJ MLP character is Adagio Dazzle. Note how she's less interested in leadership per se than she is a kind of "will-to-power"--a domination of her environment through intuitive apprehension. She's also fiercely independent and oriented toward self-possession. Her surroundings become a tool for her to achieve that aim, rather than the aim itself.

Anonymous 3228831

File: 1428207296429.png (356.04 KB, 1289x872, enneagram_of_pony_personality_…)

Dropping a related tidbit.

Silver Strength!TwiDasH7n2 3228846

File: 1428207453694.png (204.45 KB, 622x705, spike wut face.png)

>>3228831
>left out for Big Mac

Heavy Mole 3228870

File: 1428207884014.png (380.07 KB, 537x476, lucy34.png)

>>3228831
Ah, enneagram types! I've actually studied the enneagram fairly in depth but without much relation to personality typology (odd, given my fascination with mbti).

The idea is that any process can be represented in terms of nine positive realizations. Probably the most famous of these is the "hero adventure" story archetype, where a character goes on a transformative quest. However, the same symbol can be applied to using a microscope or studying history.

Each point on the enneagram has its own kind of "is-ness". The theory behind enneagram types is that we become fixated on particular points in the process (for what reason, I don't know). These fixations become obstacles for healthy behavior.

For instance, point 9 is associated with the completion of the process, and with new beginnings. It is the "unity" of the diversity represented by the two triangle points. The point 9 fixations is "peace of mind", which in practical terms translates to sloth or inaction. The remedy isn't to diversify or expand being indolent, but rather to "get thirst" represented by the triad 3-6-9.

Lisbon!EZSlut7tis 3229563

i dont wanna be fluttershit

Lisbon!EZSlut7tis 3229578

>>3225379

ho boy i got infp again
i guess im just destined to live in a tree with an asshole rabbit

Heavy Mole 3229783

>>3229578
mbti personality profiles refer to how you metabolize information, or in other words, how you take raw data and transform it into patterns of meaning. It's not the only thing which informs your personality; people who type as ISFJ, for instance, may not have any interest in fashion.

Lisbon!EZSlut7tis 3229799

>>3229783

I know, I know. I'm being foolish. Figuring out I'm INFP and there are other artsy weirdos out there was really comforting.

Eliza!zIANOLEeck 3230083

>Applejack ISTJ
>Twilight INTP
>Twilight
>INTP
>not ISTJ
pls explain

Anonymous 3231085

File: 1428283435986.jpg (357.42 KB, 1280x1554, mlp_mbti_chart_by_maran_zelde-…)

>>3228870
So I suppose I will drop the rest of the stock I have on PC.

Anonymous 3231087

File: 1428283469349.jpg (1.06 MB, 1280x1694, 468269__safe_twilight+sparkle_…)

Heavy Mole 3231098

File: 1428283733541.png (20.32 KB, 1329x549, twijack.png)

>>3230083
There are a couple of giveaways. For one, Twilight is a little more worried about fitting in than Applejack is--for example, Boast Busters, Winter Wrap-up, etc.--that's her fourth function extraverted feeling. Applejack's feeling is introverted and tertiary, so she's more willing to go against the group even if it's practically problematic. The tertiary function tends to come out under stress, and a clear example of Fi v. Si is the exchange between AJ and Twilight in the bakery in Bridle Gossip: AJ fearfully refuses to approach Zecora on the basis of subjective valuation while Twilight falls back on the "facts" of the situation to defend her argument. Her "facts" come from a logical dissection of objective valuation. "Fact" for the ISTJ plays quite a different role, one more related to mastery than method: in the face of chaos (fourth function Ne), one executes one's office and arrives at "fact" as a kind of unified reality (lead function); in Testing 123, for instance, AJ says that she learned her craft through years of working the field.

Besides, Twilight just doesn't strike me as an extraverted thinker.

Heavy Mole 3231109

File: 1428284053273.png (80 KB, 366x651, lucy279.png)

>>3231085
>>3231087
I've seen these, and obviously wasn't quite satisfied with them. Spike having introverted feeling? I strongly suspect many of these were just matching the superficial type descriptions with the character tropes.

Eliza!zIANOLEeck 3231820

>>3231098
I mean that Twilight should be ISTJ and that Applejack should be something E related, definitely not ISTJ. Maybe ESTJ since she's very tradition oriented or something like that. Applejack is definitely not an introvert, and Twilight is definitely not a philosophical thinker.

Heavy Mole 3233138

File: 1428350850134.png (74.04 KB, 236x237, lucy244.png)

>>3231820
You gotta look at the function interaction when it comes to this stuff rather than impressions based on stereotypes associated with the personality profiles. That way it has more explanatory potential, or at the very least is more interesting as a subject.

'Introverted' and 'extraverted' in Jungian typology doesn't refer to those terms in the conventional sense but rather to functions, e.g. introverted v. extraverted feeling, introverted v. extraverted thinking, etc. In a nutshell, introverted functions relate to the subject, while extraverted functions relate to objects. We all have introverted and extraverted functions in different preference order.

To take an example at hand: thinking preferences as exhibited (IMO) between Twilight and AJ. Twilight as an INTP would be a lead introverted thinker, so her thinking is going to be deductive, cataloging, basically working toward a system that makes sense to her; AJ (as an ISTJ) has auxiliary extraverted thinking, which means her logic is more "out in the room", lateral, and more oriented toward actually doing things in the real world.

The call between ESTJ and ISTJ was made based on personal experience. ESTJ's are supreme in-the-moment problem solvers but are much less oriented toward long-term stability like the ISTJ is. Conversely, they tend to have a more flexible disposition whereas the ISTJ can be impossibly stubborn. ESTJs also tend to have the attitude of "it's easier to ask forgiveness than permission" about them which, while it personally drives me bonkers irl, is an undeniable and cute part of Applebloom's character.


Delete Post [ ]
[ home ] [ site / arch ] [ pony / oat / anon ] [ rp / art ]